电影中,男主几次说过自己来自哪个单位,比如:
Lance Corporal Schofield, sir, 8th.
No, sir. I'm from the 8th.
光从字幕信息里,是很难知道这到底是第8连、第8团、第8营,还是第8军。
这要结合一战英国军队的真实编制来判断。
正确答案是男主角来自第8师(8th Division),它的指挥官是一位少将(Major-general)。符合电影中的情况。
再来看看第8师在一战时期的编成是怎样的,注意到第23旅下面出现了“德文郡团第2营”(2nd Battalion, Devonshire Regiment)
这也和电影情节相符合。
但我实在记不起公映版《1917》中是怎么翻译男主的单位的,有没有译错呢?
The division had the following organisation during World War I:
[23rd Brigade]
2nd Battalion, [Devonshire Regiment]
2nd Battalion, [Prince of Wales's Own (West Yorkshire Regiment)]
2nd Battalion, [Cameronians (Scottish Rifles)] (until February 1918)
1/6th Battalion, Cameronians (Scottish Rifles) (from March 1915 until June 1915)
2nd Battalion, [Middlesex Regiment]
1/7th Battalion, Middlesex Regiment (from March 1915 until February 1916)
[24th Brigade]
1st Battalion, [Worcestershire Regiment]
1st Battalion, [Sherwood Foresters]
2nd Battalion, [Northamptonshire Regiment]
1/5th Battalion, the [Black Watch] (until October 1915)
2nd Battalion, [East Lancashire Regiment] (to 25th Bde. February 1918)
1/4th Battalion, [Queen's Own Cameron Highlanders] (from February 1915 until April 1915)
Between October 1915 and July 1916, the 24th Brigade swapped with the [70th Brigade] from the [23rd Division].
[25th Brigade]
2nd Battalion, [Princess Charlotte of Wales's (Royal Berkshire Regiment)]
2nd Battalion, [Rifle Brigade]
1st Battalion, [Royal Irish Rifles] (until February 1918)
2nd Battalion, [Lincolnshire Regiment] (until February 1918)
2nd Battalion, East Lancashire Regiment (from 24th Bde. February 1918)
1/8th Battalion, Middlesex Regiment (from August 1915 until October 1915)
1/13th (Princess Louise) Kensington Battalion, [London Regiment] (until May 1915)
1/1st (City of London) Battalion, London Regiment (from May 1915 until February 1916)
[70th Brigade]
The 70th Brigade was from the [23rd Division] and was attached to the 8th Division between 18 October 1915, and 15 July 1916, swapping with the 24th Brigade.
Artillery
[V Brigade, Royal Horse Artillery] (left 13 January 1917)
[XXXIII Brigade, Royal Field Artillery]
[XLV Brigade, Royal Field Artillery]
[VIII Heavy Brigade, Royal Garrison Artillery] (left 5 March 1915)
Engineers
2nd Field Company, [Royal Engineers]
15th Field Company, Royal Engineers
[1/1st Home Counties Field Company], Royal Engineers (from 2 February 1915; became 490th (Home Counties) Field Company February 1917)
Pioneers
22nd (Service) Bn (3rd County Pioneers) [Durham Light Infantry] (joined 2 July 1916, until 3 July 1918)
[1/7th Bn, Durham Light Infantry] (joined from [50th (Northumbrian) Division] 20 June 1918; absorbed 22nd Bn DLI 3 July 1918)

1917的影评